The myths that kept the MFIs afloat

Microfinance is under attack. Even the normally reticent pink newspapers have now begun to bring out the inherent flaws in the microfinance model. While Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee and the Reserve Bank of India governor Mr D Subbarao refuse to take notice, public outcry against the criminal micro-credit system that has actually grown with state support, is building up.

It hasn't been that easy. When I first began exposing the fraudulent credit system in the name of the poor, I faced a barrage of criticism by the MFI employees who accused me of not appreciating the difficulties under which they were operating. Short of calling me names, they kept on expressing their 'disgust' at what I wrote, and how much little I knew about the 'wonderful' and 'humanitarian' role they were playing. Someone even went to extent of comparing the MFIs with Mother Teresa !

Nevertheless, as I went along, people began to take notice. A week after my first blog post on MFIs some months back, two young employees working in a microfinance unit contacted me, and thanked me for the "courage" demonstrated in taking the 'bull by the horn'. A day later a journalist called, and she came over to understand my perspective. I wasn't surprised when she told me that somehow she carried an impression that microfinance was a tiny loan at a tiny rate of interest.

Gradually the issue began receiving attention. More and more articles began appearing in newspapers, including vernacular language dailies. Media dug out reports submitted by district collectors in Andhra Pradesh, which showed the killing ways of MFIs. All this helped built up public pressure. Later, some Lok Sabha MPs reached me, and expressed their 'disbelief' over the unbridled exploitation of the poorest. Meanwhile, reports of suicides from Andhra Pradesh began to trickle in. The local TV channels and the print media highlighted the tragedy.

It then became a political issue. Andhra Pradesh government decided to bring in an ordinance to reign in the MFIs. Former Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu gave a call for non-repayment of the dues.

SKS Microfinance was forced to 'reduce' interest rate to 24 per cent. This kind of window dressing has to be condemned. What a reader wrote to me yesterday is so telling: “I’ve made a tonne of money… more than I ever thought I would make in my lifetime and my kid’s lifetime combined,” says Vikram Akula in a recent interview to Business Standard.

'Yes no one would crib if he became overnight a multi-billionaire tycoon. Except that he made this money by squeezing the blood of the poor and pressurizing them to take their lives while all the time cultivating an image of the "saviour of the poor," 
 
I am convinced that microfinance is actually a scam. It is inherently a flawed model in the name of reaching small credit to the poor. In reality, the MFIs are no different than the villains of the story -- money lenders. You have just read above what Vikram Akula told a newspaper. I don't have to say more. But don't think that only MFIs in India are bad. MFIs everywhere in the world are bad. In fact, if you have to see their ugliest face, just follow the MFIs in Latin America.
 
If we really need to pull the poor out of poverty, the MFIs must go. I know it is not going to be easy. I am aware of the hawks sitting in World Bank, UNDP, Ford Foundation and among numerous donors (both private and public) who are not going to let go so easily. Only public pressure can bring down the shutters on MFIs. So don't think your job is over. It has just begun.  
 
I want you to read an excellent article in today's Economic Times (Nov 11, 2010) 'Five myths about microfinance' by T T Ram Mohan. I have never met him, but I must acknowledge that if there is one economic writer that I respect, it is T T Ram Mohan. I love his incisive writings, and admire his analytical ability.
 
Five myths about microfinance
 
By T T Ram Mohan
Economic times, Nov 11, 2010
http://bit.ly/dveD5q

The microfinance bubble has burst. The AP government ordinance, the AP opposition's campaign asking borrowers not to repay and the sheer public hostility towards MFIs . all these have put the brakes on MFI activities for now. We need to rethink the role of MFIs in the rural economy . In order to do so, we must first grasp some of the myths on which the MFI sector has rested th US far.

MFIs are crucial to financial inclusion: The big impetus to financial inclusion came way back in 1969 following the nationalisation of banks. Secondly, financial inclusion is not just about giving small-ticket loans. It is also about taking deposits and providing basic banking services.

MFIs are hardly the pioneers in microfinance. The early initiative came from the self-help group (SHG) movement started by the government of India in 1992 under the auspices of Nabarad and with the involvement of banks. This is the biggest outreach programme of its kind in the world. It covers 86 million poor households and has extended credit of Rs23, 000 crore. MFIs cover 30 million customers and have lent over Rs 30,000 crore.

Under the SHG scheme, credit is linked to savings (unlike MFI credit). There is focus on capacity-building among borrowers. The rate of interest is 8-10% with monthly repayment. The suggestion that MFIs are crucial to financial inclusion is only part of an attempt to give respectability to what is increasingly a profit-driven activity.

MFIs have reached out to those ignored by banks: The contention is that MFIs complement the efforts of banks by reaching out to those ignored by banks. This too is not true. AP has an average credit/deposit ratio of over 105% and a ratio of over 80% in half the districts. (The national average is 63%). AP does not lack credit. MFIs would have been made a real contribution had they fanned out to states where the redit/deposit ratios are low. Instead, they have focused on AP.

They have done so because AP houses nearly a quarter of the SHGs. MFIs chose the easy route of tapping into established SHGs for making loans. This was viable in the early stages but, over time, it has led to the problem of multiple lending and excessive debt burdens.

It is no different from private banks in India marketing consumer loans or US banks marketing subprime loans. œ MFIs are an important mechanism for alleviating rural poverty: Credit is only one of several instruments needed for fighting poverty.

Secondly, credit can help alleviate poverty if it goes into income-generation schemes. MFI credit, for the most part, is for consumption. Thirdly, returns to agriculture are so low that it is inconceivable that it can service interest rates of 24% and above that MFIs charge. Since agriculture is the key to rural poverty, it is ridiculous to suggest that MFI credit can help alleviate poverty.

MFIs have substituted moneylenders who used to charge even higher interest rates: The comparison with moneylenders is flawed. Moneylenders donft go out and market their loans as MFIs do. Besides, moneylenders make loans strictly against collateral and this is a built-in check on lending.

Secondly, MFI interest rates in AP are said to be have been in the range of 24-60%. At the upper end, the rates are no different from those of moneylenders. Yes, MFIs did substitute moneylenders in a way because many moneylenders found it expedient to set up MFIs themselves . they could then have easy access to bank funds!

High operational costs means that smallticket loans cannot cost less than 24%: If this is true, how is lending to SHGs viable? The high lending rates of many MFIs translate into fat salaries for executives and abnormal returns. (Some have return on assets of 5%; a bank is lucky if it makes 1%).

Public sector banks (PSBs) have long had branches in the rural areas. Small loans will be one element in their portfolio which will include low-cost deposits and other products. With branch costs fully written off, it is hard to see why microfinance provided by PSBs needs to be priced at 24%. If indeed the operational costs turn out to be steep in some areas, then the bank correspondent and other models need to be developed.

PSBs have not put their best foot forward in respect of microfinance because they lack the incentives to do so. Most are listed now and have had to focus on earnings growth, which is easily provided by corporate and retail credit. The regulatory cap on interest on small loans was a dampener. (The cap is now gone). Lending to MFIs qualified as priority sector credit, so PSBs could not be troubled to build their own portfolios.

Many people think the recent problems with MFIs were the result of some excesses. With a little tweaking here and there, MFIs can be in the forefront of financial inclusion. They are wrong. The entire MFI model needs revisiting. At least PSBs are much better placed to pursue financial inclusion on their own. The AP ordinance and its fallout ensure that the go-go days for MFIs are over. And that is all to the good.

'Microfinance borrowers are forced to commit suicide'

The Allahabad High Court has yesterday termed an interest rate of 10 per cent that is being charged from defaulting farmers in Uttar Pradesh as 'cruelty' and has described it as similar to the case of 'a dying person being physically beaten.' This news comes in the wake of the leading money lender SKS Microfinance cutting down its interest rate from 24.55 to 24 per cent. This is the second time in a month when the SKS has reduced its lending rate after much hue and cry.

I wonder how come 10 per cent interest being charged from a farmer becomes 'cruelty' whereas 24 per cent rate being charged from his wife in the name of micro finance goes under the category of 'humanitarian' support?

It is therefore quite obvious that micro finance is designed to exploit the poor, and draw every ounce of blood from the hapless poor. And yet, Vijay Mahajan, the CEO of another big money lending firm Basix, has the audacity to say: "There is a need for a study on the suicides by independent social scientists. If the suicides are proved to be due to the activities of MFIs, we will compensate the family and take punitive action against the erring staff."

Why only the erring staff? Why not you, Mr Vijay Mahajan?

And this also reminds me of what the apathatic government officials invariably say whenever news reports of starvation deaths come out. Every time I remember they would contest the news reports by saying that these deaths are not due to starvation but some chronic diseases. Vijay Mahajan is no different.

Business Standard (Nov 10, 2010) quotes K Venkatanarayana of Kakatiya University, who has been studying MFI sector in Andhra Pradesh. He says borrowers are forced to commit suicide. “During training sessions, MFIs say a loan will be waived if the person who had taken it dies. This could be working in a negative manner," he explains.

Wasn't I right? The MFIs are designed to kill. And yet, the killers are roaming free. Why is Andhra Pradesh government not filing FIRs against them? Just look at the four case studies that are pasted below. Why should these widows not get justice? Why shouldn't the MFIs responsible for the deaths of their near and dear be held for murder?

Meanwhile, here is the Business Standard report:

AP suicides raise questions on MFI model

Warangal November 10, 2010

Ban multiple lending, bring about greater transparency, slash interest rates. Only that can salvage the sector, say activists

As the high-rises of Hyderabad fade away, verdant greenery and a cool breeze take over. Early morning, we are travelling through beautiful terrain on our way to Warangal. Once there, however, nature is no solace.

A deafening calm greets us at Venkatadripet near Ghanpur station. In the past couple of months, several residents of this hamlet have faced the alleged coercive methods of micro finance institutions (MFIs) for defaulting on repayments. Their only recourse: taking their own lives.

With the death toll climbing, the government had to finally step in. But heart-wrenching stories of the victims’ families still hang heavy in the air. Warangal district is the worst hit, with 17 suicides reported from the area. Andhra Pradesh reportedly has 57 cases of harassment, including suicides.

R Subrahmanyam, principal secretary, rural development, Andhra Pradesh, minces no words. He says MFIs are raking in hyper-profits at the cost of the rural poor. “MFIs are also resorting to multiple lending without conducting due diligence.”

K Venkatanarayana of Kakatiya University, who has been studying MFI sector in the state closely, says borrowers are forced to commit suicide. “During training sessions, MFIs say a loan will be waived if the person who had taken it dies. This could be working in a negative manner,” he explains.

MFIs charge an interest rate of 26-32 per cent. “This is exorbitant,” says Venkatanarayana. “MFIs have deviated from their path of serving the poor. They are just pushing the poor into a debt trap by multiple lending and lending beyond the capacity of borrowers. There are many MFIs operating in the same area and function on joint legal liability. The model is based on pure profit.”

However, MFIs counter accusations of usury, claiming the interest on a loan includes the cost of finding customers in remote places, appraising them and selecting the creditworthy, disbursing money and collecting repayments for over 50 weeks, administration and raising funds.

“Banks don’t go to the doorstep to offer loans. We ensure that a borrower does not lose a single day’s earnings,” says P Kishore Kumar, managing director, Trident Microfinance, adding that the interest includes insurance cover. There are around 100 MFIs operating in AP, of which only 18 are registered, he adds.

Venkatanarayana blames commercial banks for the mess created by MFIs. “Banks do not want to invest in the rural poor. Reaching out to the poor means investing in infrastructure, manpower and other activities, which they are unwilling to do.”

Kishore Kumar says moneylenders are now calling themselves MFIs. “That’s the reason we have started taking corrective measures. The Microfinance Institutions Network (MFIN), the industry body, was formed with this very purpose.”

To address the issues, the Andhra Pradesh government issued an ordinance on October 15 to protect borrowers from exploitation by MFIs. But has the damage been already done?

MFIN, while agreeing that there might be some aberrations, argues that the ordinance will affect the financial inclusion plans of the government. “There is a need for a study on the suicides by independent social scientists. If the suicides are proved to be due to the activities of MFIs, we will compensate the family and take punitive action against the erring staff. If required, the MFI will be expelled from MFIN,” says Vijay Mahajan, founder of Basix and CEO of MFIN.

Ban multiple lending, bring about greater transparency, slash interest rates and monitor the end-use of loans. These are some of the steps that can be introduced to salvage the MFI sector and make it successful, say activists. But should these not have been done before the MFIs started operating? The Warangal deaths are ample answer to that question.

CASE 1: Ranjitha

Everyone knew K Ramesh. His wife, Ranjitha, borrowed Rs 10,000 from Spandana, an MFI, to buy a buffalo. The family paid 15 weekly instalments of Rs 225 each. But she could not keep up with the repayments. She was part of a group of villagers, who had taken loans. The first time she defaulted, other members of the group pooled in and paid her instalment. But soon after, they insisted that Ramesh clear the dues. Spandan’s agents also started hounding them. Ranjitha doused herself with kerosene and set it alight. The following day, Ramesh hanged himself. Ranjitha was hospitalised with burns, but survived. “If you borrow in a group, you have to repay in a group. That was the diktat,” she says.

CASE 2: KAUSAR

Twenty-two-year-old Kausar, a resident of Warangal, is buckling. She has a two-year-old son and a Rs 10,000-loan to be repaid. She paid 25 instalments on time. But then her child met with an accident and the money was spent on treatment. She again borrowed Rs 12,000 from Swayamkrushi and took another Rs 12,000 through a friend. With medical expenses mounting, she found herself unable to make her repayments. Members of the group threatened to sit in front of her house. This prompted Akbar, her husband, to take the extreme step: suicide. The insurance cover would take care of Kausar’s loans, but she still has to repay the loan taken on her behalf by her friend.

CASE 3: ALIYA

“MFIs don’t crosscheck if a loan was used for the intended purpose,” says Suresh, a friend of Baskaa Aliya in Kadapikonda near Kazipet. Aliya committed suicide after failing to repay money owed to MFIs. His wife, Hyma, had borrowed Rs 40,000 from Sharemoolah and Spandana. Suresh pays Rs 625 a week for the Rs 26,000 loan that his wife had taken. Agents highlight the long-winded procedures that banks follow to sanction loans. This deters the poor from approaching them. They also believe getting a loan from banks is too difficult a job for the likes of Aliya and is the main reason the Andhra government's Paavala Vaddi (loans at 25-paise interest) scheme is not utilised.

CASE 4: RAMA

Multiple borrowing ruined Rama’s life. Her teenage daughter, E Mownika, set herself ablaze after lenders repossessed her sewing machine. She succumbed to her injuries. Her father also suffered burns in an effort to save her. Rama, a resident of Karimabad, had taken loans from five MFIs. The family is yet to return Rs 1,00,000, including Rs 50,000 to Pragati. They used to pay Rs 5,300 every month, but defaulted three months ago. “The agents would tell us to sell household items to repay,” she alleges. Rama had taken loans to expand her business. Her husband runs a paan shop. After falling into a debt trap, she ended up taking fresh loans to repay earlier loans.

http://mediatoday.co.in/stories_discription.php?id=23732

Obama's visit: Fate of Millions of Farmers Hangs in Balance

From: Economic Times, Nov 9, 2010
http://bit.ly/bBHGLX

He came, he spoke, and he got 54,000 jobs. This was on Day One of his India visit. By the time he flies out of New Delhi on November 9, US President Barack Obama would have charmed his way through to force open Indian agriculture to American corporations . And therein hangs the fate of millions of small and marginal farmers.

Top on the agenda is the push to make Prime Minister Manmohan Singh allow the entry of multi-brand food retail. “Agriculture sector needs well functioning markets to drive growth, employment and economic prosperity in rural areas,” says a discussion paper drafted by the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion sometimes ago. Nothing could be further away from truth, but then the G-20 has made it obligatory for member countries to open up for big retail.

Nowhere in the world has big retail helped farmers. In the US, despite the growth of big retail like Wal-Mart and Carrefour, farmers number has dwindled and come down to such a low level that America has stopped counting its farmers since the 2000 census. Meanwhile, hunger has broken a 14-year record, and poverty is on an upswing. In Europe, notwithstanding the presence of Tesco, one farmer quits agriculture every minute. For India too, multi-brand retail will be the beginning of the end for Indian farmers. No assessment has ever been made of the extent of job losses in the farm sector as a result.

If big retail in food is capable of raising farm incomes I see no reason why the US should be providing monumental subsidies to the tune of $307 billion for five years, beginning 2008. The same holds true for Europe where farmers survive because the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) bails them out with direct income support. In both Europe and America, nearly 80% farm subsidies go to the big corporations. Neither the World Trade Organisations (WTO) nor has the US Fed ever tried to rationalise these wasteful farm subsidies.

It is primarily because of such huge farm subsidies that global food prices slumps thereby pricing out the Indian farmers. An UNCTAD-India study had conclusively shown that if the Green Box subsidies were to be withdrawn, the US agriculture would collapse. The US is therefore trying to pierce open the developing country agriculture essentially to sustain its own economy.

President Obama has made this abundantly clear when he repeatedly talks of seeking more market access from India. Unfortunately, Manmohan Singh has never sought reciprocity. I wonder how many more human lives are required to be sacrificed before the most powerful person on earth takes notice, and revive global farming by encouraging low external-input sustainable agriculture.

When will America open its markets, Mr Obama?

I have a great respect for US President Barack Obama. I admire his intellect, and of course his ability to mesmerise the audience with his brilliant expositions. I know he stands tall, and exudes confidence and hope.

There is no denying that in today's world where political leaders are merely rubber stamps for business and industry, Obama does have the ability to chart out a new pathway. But the more I see him hardselling the unwanted merchandise from the US corporations, the more I feel sad. As much as he may want us to believe in the ideals of Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King, the fact remains that he himself is no where even remotely closer to following what the 'global hero' (as he calls Gandhi) had preached.

Obama is in reality a prisoner of the corporate world. Knowingly or unknowingly, he is trapped in a vicious cycle of economic growth that is plundering the natural resources and making this planet inhospitable.  

The sooner the US President sheds the black corporate robe that keeps him chained to promote unsustainable economic growth, the better it would be for a world that is looking up to him as perhaps the lone saviour who has the ability to stem the rot. I only hope that like his predecessors he too does not disappoint. Only history will tell.

When he told a group of students in Mumbai yesterday: "Well, if our country is open to everybody, countries that trade with the US have to change their practices," I think he was merely echoing what the business leaders accompanying him had briefed him. This is where the President has been wrongly informed. This is where he is behaving more like a salesman for the corporates whose arm-twisting antics in WTO and numerous bilaterals being signed world over have still not opened up the kind of market they always dream.

Let me take this opportunity to draw attention to two contentious areas of free trade: agriculture and pharmaceuticals. It is here that US is trying every trick of the trade to stop imports. It is here that the US is refusing to open up its markets, and its policies are actually killing farmers in Africa, Latin America and Asia.

1. Former US President Bill Clinton had recently apologised for flooding Haiti since early 1990s with cheaper American rice, which had destroyed Haiti's ability to feed itself. If Mr Obama is presented with the stark facts of how unjust has the WTO been so far, I am sure he would like to apologise for what the US has done to harm developing country agriculture and food security. This is what Bill Clinton had said: “It may have been good for some of my farmers in Arkansas, but it has not worked. It was a mistake.

Clinton—now a UN special envoy to Haiti—told the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee March 10, 2010. “I had to live everyday with the consequences of the loss of capacity to produce a rice crop in Haiti to feed those people because of what I did; nobody else." [read the fill report at http://devinder-sharma.blogspot.com/2010/05/bill-clinton-apologises-for-flooding.html

2. In 2001, nearly 25,000 US cotton growers received roughly $3.9 billion in subsidy payments, for producing a cotton crop that was worth only US$ 3 billion at world market prices (One Arkansas cotton grower received US$ 6 million, equal to the combined annual earnings of 25,000 cotton farmers in Mali). It's also more than the gross domestic product of several African countries and three times the amount the US spends on aid to half a billion Africans living in poverty. In 2002, direct financial assistance by a number of exporting countries, including China, European Union and the US, to the tune of 73 per cent of the world cotton production, destroyed millions of livelihoods in West African countries (Benin, Burkina Faso, Mali, and Chad). India and Pakistan too have been forced to lower import duties, allowing a surge of cotton imports thereby pushing farmers out. [read my article The Great Trade Robbery, available at: http://www.countercurrents.org/en-sharma020903.htm]

And what did the US do, Mr President? Instead of doing away with cotton subsidies, it actually bribed Brazil, which had won a case against the US in the WTO dispute panel. It offered to subsidise instead Brazil's rich cotton growers to the tune of $ 147.3 million a year. This is a small fee to ensure that Brazil keeps its mouth shut, which also means that the US can continue to distort the global cotton market by the huge subsidies it provides to its rich and pampered cotton growers. [read my analysis: http://devinder-sharma.blogspot.com/2010/04/us-bribes-brazil-with-147-million-in.html]

3. Although 80 per cent of US monumental agricultural subsidies go to the agribusiness industry, the US continues to increase its farm support. This makes the international prices slump as a result of which US farm produce becomes 'competitive.' A recent UNCTAD-India study had categorically brought out that if the US were to do away with its Green Box subsidies, its farm output would dip by over 40 per cent. This will bring in cheaper food exports from developing countries. Mr President, it is the massive subsidies you dole out for your agribusiness companies that the US market becomes inaccessible. On top of it, US has thrown in non-trade barriers to keep the agricultural imports out.

4. You want India to provide more market access. What you probably are not aware is that India has already gone in for an autonomous liberalisation and has opened up its market. This happened in March 2008 when George Bush wanted India to open up, before the US could reciprocate. The import tariffs for the most important farm commodities have already been brought down to zero. Wheat import tariff is zero, rice is at zero (whenever US asks us to do), maize is at zero, pulses is at zero, edible oils is practically zero (or 7.5 per cent as the case may be for some categories), what further reduction do you expect now?

India opened up, but the US did not reciprocate. The US in fact approved the US Farm Bill 2008 that makes a provision for an additional farm subsidy of $ 307 billion for the next five year. Come on, Mr President show us that you mean business, and that you follow ethics and justice in trade. When will you start reducing agricultural subsidies so as to provide market access for developing country agricultural products?

5. You want us to accept GM foods. You also want India to open up for the agricultural commodities. What you are probably not aware is that it is because of the industrially produced food that US today supports the sickest population on earth. US has more people living with Alzheimer, dementia, cancer, allergies, autism, APHD, and diabetes than any other country in the world. As far as GM foods are concerned, please tell which laws in the US makes it mandatory for the companies to do safety tests. The bio tech companies do their own tests, evaluate their results, declare the crops safe, and all that the regulators do is to stamp the approval.

Why do you want India to import such unhealthy foods, just because it benefits US corporations?

6. A sick nation needs affordable medicines. No one knows it much better than you. But as Health GAP (Global Access Project) states: "The US as well as European countries are also challenging India to grant monopoly protection to the data that drug companies use to obtain regulatory approval for a medicine. This measure, called "data exclusivity," would undermine cost cutting generic competition by delaying the entry of generics to market. Data exclusivity is not required by the World Trade Organization?but pharmaceutical companies have pushed aggressively for it. India's refusal to create a regime of data exclusivity was another feature of its Special 301 Report listing.

As a result, India's ability to make low cost, generic versions of newer medicines is under threat, and U.S.-funded AIDS treatment programs will be forced to waste money procuring more costly medicines. Isn't it time that you provide more market access for generic drugs from India, which alone produces 80 per cent of world's requirements of cheaper drugs?

Mr President, providing more market access for agriculture and pharmaceuticals by the US too is a 'win-win' situation. Try that, and I can assure you much of your problems in health and unsustainable farming would be taken care of. Michelle Obama has already shown the way by turning White House lawns organic, and also by launching a nationwide campaign to reduce diabetes among children. You will helping her, as well as billions across the world by providing more market access for agriculture and pharmaceuticals.

Obama's India visit: Where India fails

One thing that I admire about American President's is that they know what they want. In the last 10 years or so whenever I have read about an American President visiting China, India, Vietnam, Indonesia and other countries, I have always noticed that before the US President leaves the American shores, he would announce that he is going to return with so many jobs.

President Obama is no exception. And within hours of reaching India, he managed to bag 53,000 jobs for America. By the time he flies out of New Delhi on Nov 9, I am sure he would have added another 50,000 or so.

When was the last time you heard the Indian Prime Minister say so. Except for the use of usual cliches like ' it is a goodwill visit' and 'the visit will strengthen the ties,' I don't know what our successive Prime Ministers have achieved all these years from such state visits. Except for a few business deals, I think successive Indian Prime Ministers have actually failed the nation. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh is no exception.

Compare this with China. During the term of President Clinton, he made a statement that the US will not trade with China because of its bad human rights record. Within a day or so the big US corporations made life tough for Bill Clinton, but more significant was the courage and political statesmanship shown by the then Chinese President. I remember watching the BBC World TV Beijing correspondent asking the question to the Chinese President. His reply was: "Trading with America, we never trade with America for the last 4000 years. So how does it matter."

The US has never again brought up the human rights issue.

Remember Manmohan Singh's visit to G-20 Summit in Toronto after the Bhopal gas tragedy court verdict. He didn't even have the courage to talk about justice for Bhopal victims when he met President Obama in Toronto. What can you expect from such spineless leadership.

President Obama knows what he wants. He wants India to provide more market access for the American manufacturing and agricultural products. And he wants India to provide jobs in America. He has come to sell American hardware, and with India Inc. in tow, he knows he will get what he wants.

The tragedy is that India does not even know what it needs to get from America. If you have been following the endless debates and discussions on the TV, it is obvious that we are a confused nation. Most of the experts on the show are not talking business, but giving us a feel of how much they know about strategic relations. This is because they are completely cut-off from the realities of the ongoing economic developments that are shaping the upheavals in the global economy.

I was therefore very surprised when I heard a Mumbai student (when interviewed by a TV journalist today) as to what he intends to ask President Obama when he meets the generation next on Sunday morning. He replied that he is going to ask about the unjust TRIPs and TRIMs agreements which are heavily loaded against the developing countries, and which would lead to the rich becoming richer and the poor being driven to the wall.

I bet the correspondent didn't know anything about TRIPs or TRIMs !

No wonder, while the US has come with a laundry list, India has no such shopping list. Except for the controversial issue of outsourcing (which is nothing compared to market access that India should be seeking in the US), there is nothing that seems to be on the radar screen. If you have no shopping list, you have no reason to complain later.

US knows where it has to walk the extra mile for its own strategic business interests. India does not even know how to take advantage of the huge market that it can offer to the American corporations. We are on a position of strength. Even if America has the sophisticated technology (not much of it is actually required in India), it desperately requires customers to buy it. Otherwise it is only a matter of time before the American company pulls down the shutters in the absence of buyers.

Remember George Bush when he came to India in 2006. Media had played up the story of the US willing to allow imports of Indian mangoes. In return, the US had wanted access for selling its Harley-Davidson motorcycles. What is little known is that while India lowered the emission norms to allow the sub-standard motorcycle into India, the US has still not softened the sanitary and phytosanitary standards that blocks the entry of mangoes.

India is a Mango Republic.  

Obama’s Visit: US Merchants eyeing Indian agriculture

At a time when America is faced with an economic downtrend, US President Barack Obama comes calling in a few days hoping that India will bail him out of the seemingly unending economic crisis. With a huge business team – more than 200 top business chiefs -- accompanying him, US is expecting to increase it exports to India by at least 400 per cent.

Food and Agriculture is one of the major thrust areas where President Obama is likely to make a strong pitch.

In 2006, the last time the US President visited India, George Bush had formally launched the Rs 1000-crore Indo-US Knowledge Initiative in Agricultural Research and Education, when he made a quick visit to Hyderabad. For years later, in 2010, the Indo-US Knowledge Initiative (KIA) appears to be almost in a cold storage, but after having successfully promoted unwanted US technologies on several farm universities.

This followed from the previous visit of prime minister Manmohan Singh to Washington in 2005. Addressing a joint session of the US Congress during his visit, prime minister had said: “The Green Revolution lifted countless millions above poverty.... I am very happy to say that U.S. President George Bush and I have decided to launch second generation of India-US collaboration in agriculture."

Following the agreement, a team of Indian agricultural scientists visited US in December 2005 to work out the modalities of the programme. It was followed by a return visit by US agricultural scientists, and the entire exercise has been kept confidential and prepared in a hush-hush manner.

It was feared that the Indo-US agricultural treaty would bring Indian agriculture under the direct control of US Corporate houses. The dominance of the American agri-business became clear when it became known that the US supermarket giant Wal-Mart, food giant Cargill and the seed multination Monsanto were on the board of the Indo-US Initiative. All these companies are now well entrenched, ready for the next phase.

President Obama is likely to re-energise the dead Indo-US Knowledge Initiative in Agriculture. Since the agreement is facing un-surmountable hurdles because of the inability of the Indian Council for Agricultural Research (ICAR) to pay for staff travels and technologies being imported, it is likely that the US would push through more collaboration in agricultural scientific research through the US-India Strategic Dialogue.

While collaboration in farm research will pave the way for the entry of US agribusiness multinationals, especially technology companies like Monsanto and Du Pont, the thrust of the US talks is going to be on opening up of the food retail and insurance sector. A few weeks back, President Obama had expressed hope that India would allow FDI in big retail. The G-20 Summit in Toronto some months back had also in its final communiqué decided to lift all hurdles to allow big retail to operate.

As a welcome gesture, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh is likely to announce the formal approval for FDI in big retail. It was primarily to justify the need for FDI in retail that the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP) had come out with a highly flawed discussion paper to indicate government’s rethinking on the controversial subject. “The agriculture sector needs well functioning markets to drive growth, employment and economic prosperity in rural areas,” the discussion paper said. A number of economists and researchers joined the chorus singing praise for the role the supermarkets can play.

Despite the destruction of farming globally by the supermarkets, the Ministry for Commerce and Industry is gung-ho about allowing foreign direct investment in multi-brand retailing, which means allowing the big players like Wal-Mart and Tesco to swamp the Indian market. Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar has time and again spelt out the need to allow FDI in big retail. Ministry for Commerce had even set up a small committee to prepare the ground for its entry.

If the supermarkets were so efficient and provided dynamism, I would like to know why the US is providing a massive subsidy for agriculture. After all, the world biggest retail giant Wal-mart is based in America and it should have helped American farmers to become economically viable. But it did not happen. American farmers have instead been bailed out by the government, providing a subsidy of Rs 12.50 lakh-crore between 1995 and 2009, and this includes direct income support.

The supermarkets have therefore failed the American farmers.

India is therefore importing a failed economic model, which otherwise would help the economic recovery of America.

Entry of the big US food retail signals the complete corporate takeover of Indian agriculture. At a time when the government is busy laying out the infrastructure for the 2nd Green Revolution, which means strengthening agribusiness, a plethora of Indian laws on water, seeds, pesticides, fertilisers, land use policy, contract farming, biodiversity, intellectual property, biotechnology and genetic engineering have either been suitably amended (or are in the process) to facilitate the entry of multinational companies. One of the major thrust areas where Manmohan Singh is expected to assure President Obama of his un-stinted support is the introduction of the controversial genetically engineered crops.

India has already prepared a bill – National Biotechnology Regulatory Authority bill -- awaiting introduction in parliament that allows for a single-window clearance for genetically-modified crops, something that even the US does not allow within its own borders.

In the last few weeks, multinational companies like Monsanto, Wal-Mart and also the US Grain Council has been making a fervent pitch to life the barriers that have come in the way of US exports to India. It is not without reason that the Ministry of Commerce has been seeking fast conclusion of the Doha round of the World Trade Organisation. In the last few weeks, the US has forced Russia to cut down its agricultural subsidies by 50 per cent as a pre-requisite for its entry as a member of the WTO. It is also asking India, Brazil and China to further reduce the industrial tariffs.

India is expected to assure President Obama that it will not press for the reduction of the massive US farm subsidies, especially in cotton, but will provide more market access to US farm goods. All non-trade barriers are being gradually removed, and the US will find it easy to rebuild its sagging economy on the strength of the Indian market.

Indian agriculture provides a sustained market for the US companies. What is good for the commercial interest of the US companies is not necessarily going to be productive for Indian farmers. But then, Manmohan Singh has time and again talked of shifting 70 per cent of the rural population into the urban centres. Bringing agriculture under the yoke of the US business and industry will hasten this population transfer.

Small borrowers must stop repaying the loans from MFIs. This is the only way to curb the social evil

Yesterday, when the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) announced the credit policy review in Mumbai, I was discussing the implications on a national TV. Within minutes of the announcement of the upward revision in repo and reverse repo rates -- sixth time this year -- I found that the media focus had shifted to the tightening of the home loans. It was then that I asked a question as to why the RBI had refrained from tightening the screws on the micro-finance segment.

For some strange coincidence, the UPA President Sonia Gandhi who was addressing the All India Congress Committee (Rajdeep Sardesai of CNN-IBN later in show extended the acronymn AICC to 'All India Crooks Corner') at the same time, also skipped talking about rampant corruption within the party. Is it merely a coincidence or a pointer to the evil that the Congress party as well as the RBI is finding it too hot to handle?

I thought my poser on the TV show had gone unnoticed. But I was pleasantly surprised when I found George Mathew of the Indian Express (Nov 3, 20101) asking the same question to the RBI governor D Subbarao. He asked: Microfinance companies are charging very high interest rates. Why is the RBI not doing anything to bring them down?

Subbarao replied: "The RBI regulates only one segment of the MFI sector, which is the non-banking finance companies involved in the microfinance sector. There’s no such separate categorisation of NBFC-MFIs. There are 37 NBFCs which are MFIs and regulated by us and none of them are deposit taking. Only about 13 out of 37 NBFCs are systematically important with business of over Rs 100 crore. The segment of the MFI sector that comes under RBI regulation is small but in terms of total lending, it might be significantly higher. Now there are questions about regulating interest rates and our stance is to move away from regulating interest rates. We can’t now turn towards this and start regulating interest rates. In any case, this is a question that Malegam committee will go through and we will take a view after the report is available." 

While this may be partly true, I think the RBI (like the Congress party) is trying to turn a blind eye to the gory ongoings in the MFI sector. How can the RBI governor first express helplessness, and then say that 'in any case, this is a question that Malegam committee will go through and we will take a view after the report is available." Does it mean that Malegam committee will give additional regulatory powers to RBI? The answer is No. The RBI is simply trying to avoid taking a harsh decision lest it reflects on the lending rates of the nationalised banks (which provides refinance to MFIs and others).

Only a few days back, the Sunday Indian Express (Oct 24, 2010) had in a full-page article entitled Andhra's Small-Debt Trap (Read the full report at: http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/Andhras-smalldebt-trap/701577/) written by Sreenivas Janayala clearly brought out the malaise that afflicts the micro-finance sector. It quoted R Subramaniam, Principal Secretary, Rural Development, Andhra Pradesh, as saying: “But it is the fine print in the clauses and loan agreement that really create the debt trap. When borrowers fail to pay one EMI, the additional interest is calculated at double or triple the interest rate. The interest continues to remain the same until the principal amount is paid off. More often than not, the final interest rate works to nearly 50 per cent.”

Now please tell me, isn't this shameful? Does it make the MFIs any different from the moneylenders that they depict as the villain of the story?

On Oct 16, the Andhra Pradesh government, for the first time in the history of India, promulgated an ordinance, restraining the MFIs from using coercive tactics to recover loans and weekly interest, and keep lending rates in check. This is only one part of the criminal activity that MFIs indulge in. In my understanding, as numerous reports/studies have shown, the main problem is the high interest rate that is being charged from the small borrowers. The AP government as well as the RBI is silent on this. The conspiracy of silence is taking a human toll.

The answer lies in what I had first suggested some days ago on this blog. I had asked small borrowers (including the SHGs) to stop paying back the loans. I am glad the former chief minister Chandrababu Naidu, who is on a three day visit to Ranga Reddy district, also asked "women who have taken loans not to repay till interest rates are reduced."

In a democracy, people must raise their voice. They must express their anger in a peaceful way so that the powers that be sit back and take notice. MFIs charge such exorbitant interests because the nation does not care nor is it aware. The MFIs will come under pressure only of we exert that pressure. As Rajan Alexander has in a letter to Ground Reality wrote: "And how do know they are vulnerable? Because Vijay Mahajan, the father of MFIs in India tells us so:

“We are facing collapse. Unless something changes on the ground, the industry as we know it is basically gone.”

Mahajan, we have news for you. The day when the likes of you are gone, that will be the turning point for the fight against poverty!"