Showing posts with label Olivier de Schutter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Olivier de Schutter. Show all posts

Ever heard of Growth blindness? If not, you too may be suffering from it.

There are generally two kinds of eye problems that people face. There is myopia, short-sightedness. And then there is hyperopia, far-sightedness. But over the years, another major eye defect has emerged. It is called growth blindness. Almost all educated, even if they happen to suffer from either myopia or hyperopia, are falling to growth blindness. Universities and educational institutes are churning out graduates and post-graduates (not to talk of people passing out from Business Schools) who are made to believe in the magic potion of growth.

The newspapers are full of reports and quotes about growth. Finance Ministers (everywhere in the world) swear in the name of economic growth. TV anchors (most of them have not ventured out of their plush offices for years) are hung on economic growth. That is what they have read in the university, and if they ever try to question the growth paradigm the business house owning the channel will throw them out. And they know for sure -- getting a job again even at times of rising growth is not easy.

So basically, it's all about protecting and saving your job. Whether it is a journalist, economist, academician, credit rating analyst or a politician, singing the growth chorus helps them to save their job.

Growth blindness is a manufactured disease. It's an economic system that money has been able to create. Take the example of oil spills. Do you want more oil spills to happen or do you think these spills are a disaster for environment and health? Well, a Houston-based Oil pipeline company recently acknowledged that "Spill response and clean-up created business opportunities for affected communities, regions and clean-up service providers." In other words, oil spills help in raising GDP or growth. Oil Company argues oil spills are good for the economy. (http://www.thewire.com/business/2014/05/oil-company-argues-oil-spills-are-good-for-the-economy/361551/

When Oxfam International tells us that the wealth of 85 people equals that of 3.2 billion, we categorise it as growing inequality. When we are told that the income of 0.1 per cent among the top 1 per cent of the American population has gained the most from the multi-billion dollar bailout packages that somehow stalled the collapse of global economy in 2008-09, we heave a sigh of relief.  We don't want to read the second para that tells us that the income gains for the remaining 99 per cent was in the negative. We know this is inevitable. We also know this is unfair and unjust. But we prefer not to question. Questioning will automatically put a stop to your own growth. Better to keep mum.

When we are told that 80 per cent of Americans live in 'near poverty' we just ignore. When we read that pollution levels in China and India are reaching dangerous levels, we take it as if it is a small time sacrifice that people must make for the sake of growth. When the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) tells us that the world is getting closer to a tripping point, we go back to textbooks which tells us that every disaster is a business opportunity. Meaning more growth.

There is a limit to growth.

In their paper The Making of an Economist (Journal of Economic Perspective. 1987), Colander and Klamer gave an explanation for economic blindness. They concluded that it primarily lies in an educational system that pumps out economists who are utterly clueless as to how the world economy operates. These textbook economists go out and then preach whatever the textbooks prescribe. Often I mention when it comes to rising inflation, I find most of these economist blame supply-demand constrains for the rising food prices. That's what they have been taught in their colleges. They can't think beyond that. But when I say there is no supply constraint, they are baffled. Not knowing what to say, they go on repeating ad nauseam that inflation is the outcome of supply-demand constraints. 

Over the years, a handful of thinkers, includes some economists, have begun the question the sustainability of growth economics. Their number is growing with each passing week. While the objective of this piece is not to take you through the corridors of alternative to growth economics that is building up, I want you to take a look at this latest initiative by Olivier de Shutter, who till recently was the UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food. He has called for a conference: The EU's 5th Project: transitional Governance in the Service of Sustainable Societies to be held at Brussels May 8-9 2014.  

Olivier says: “We need alternatives to GDP growth as the goal of public policy, and we need alternatives to work and wealth accumulation as the driving forces in our lives. A genuine transition in the way we live is the only true path to sustainability. But it must be accompanied by a transition in the way we govern. This is Europe’s fifth project.” I agree.

The EU5th Project Conference (link here: http://stanford.io/1o5EVyM) is asking a few key questions. These are the basic questions that every sensible person should be asking:
I am sure some of you will have some additional pertinent questions. This is just a beginning, and in the days to come the alternatives to growth blindness will gradually emerge. There are already distinguished people working on a radical overhaul of the food systems, making it more local and sustainable. There are social entrepreneurs, academicians, thinkers, writers and activists who are talking of Economics of Happiness. There are environmental movements across the globe that are fighting for bringing in some sanity in the economic growth paradigm. Their voice is growing. Another World is Possible was a powerful slogan some years back. And that I think is the best hope that I see on horizon.

The movement for alternative to the faulty growth economics model is now growing. Occupy movement, Arab Spring and India's fight against corruption were essentially part of the same thought process. The World Social Forum takes it to another level. Meanwhile, concerned citizens, smaller groups are coming together, forming alliances and networks. One such event being planned  is titled "For a successful XXI century, let's build alternatives to fear, violence and war!" at Lyon, July 4-6. http://dialoguesenhumanite.org/lyon/1175/programme-2014.

I will continue to update you with relevant information as and when I can lay my hands upon. 

Meanwhile, stand up and be counted. It's time to remove growth blindness. At stake is your own survival, and the future of your children. You can't leave a dead planet behind. #

My $ 1 Trillion Plan: Enough to wipe out hunger, poverty and disease from India.

Every now and then I read about the desperate need to invest $ 1 trillion in infrastructure projects in India. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has reiterated this time and again. Addressing the Asian Development Bank at Manila in May, former Finance Minister (and now the President of India) Pranab Mukherjee said: "India needs about USD 1 trillion in the next five years for infrastructure development, out of which at least 50 per cent has to come from the private sector. Therefore, there is a huge scope for investments in India." He of course also said that the focus remains on inclusive growth.

In June 2012, Manmohan Singh outlined his plan (see India's $ 1 Trillion Plan. http://www.energyandcapital.com/articles/indias-1-trillion-plan/2246) while speaking at a meeting of the Ministers and Secretaries concerned with the departments of power, railway, road, shipping, civil aviation, and coal besides of course the Planning Commission. He said:“India is at a critical juncture in its quest for prosperity and eradication of poverty...We are running into more turbulent weather...There is a need to revive business and investor sentiments...and a need to create an atmosphere conducive to investment ... In the short term, development of infrastructure will boost investment rates across the economy. In the long run, it will remove the supply constraints that affect economic activity in agriculture, industry and trade.”
 
If you would have noticed, he began by saying that India is at a critical juncture in its quest for prosperity and eradication of poverty (emphasis mine). In other words, it means the basic purpose of seeking $ 1 trillion investment is to pull the country out of dismal poverty and hunger. Following the trickle down theory, what the Prime Minister is suggesting is that the more investment we make in creating infrastructure the more it will help in removing poverty and hunger. I had posed this question some years back to late Dr Mehbub-ul-Haq, a former Finance Minister of Pakistan, who was also the founder editor of the UN Human Development Report. He replied: "We were wrongly taught that we should take care of GDP and it will automatically take care of poverty. Let us reverse it. We need to take care of poverty and it will automatically take care of GDP." (You can read my Aug 2000 article Poverty: Look beyond GDP growth. http://www.twnside.org.sg/title/2086.htm).

Since 75-80 per cent of the world's poor do not have any social protection, the UN Special Rapporteur on Right to Food Dr Olivier de Schutter has called for a Global Fund for Social Protection (GFSP). Accordingly, 2-6 per cent of global GDP, or $ 1.26 trillion to 3.79 trillion (based on 2010 GDP figures) needs to be ensured for providing comprehensive rights-based social protection schemes that reduce vulnerabilities of local populations and provides them security (See the executive summary at: http://www.srfood.org/images/stories/pdf/otherdocuments/20121009_gfsp_execsummary_en.pdf).

Olivier de Schutter is demanding a minimum of $1.26 trillion to ensure social livelihood protection for the world's poor. For a country like India, which has one-third of the world's hungry and an equal percentage of poverty stricken, plus where 47 per cent children below the age of five continue to be malnourished, its share would be much less. But given the magnitude of the crisis, and knowing that poverty eradication is not as simple and straight forward as is generally made out to be, I still feel that what Mehbub-ul-Haq had said is the ultimate way out. The $ 1 Trillion investment on infrastructure development is not going to make any appreciable dent on poverty removal. It has to be the other way around. Make investments on the human capital -- removing poverty, hunger and disease -- and we will see a stupendous rise in economic growth.

If I were in place of Dr Manmohan Singh, my $ 1 Trillion Plan would be radically different from his. I would aim primarily at removing hunger and poverty. I would begin by first ensuring food security at the household level, ensuring local production, local procurement and local distribution. Food security has to be an integrated part of the cropping system whereby sustainable agriculture would get a massive thrust. Turning farming into an economically viable proposition would sow the seeds of not only reverse migration but also ushering in rural prosperity. I an never forget a Punjabi saying: "Jeede ghar daane, ude bachhe bhi sayanne." Translated it means that he who has ample food in his house, his children would be healthy, wealthy and wise. 

Poverty eradication therefore has to be directly linked with household food security.

My objective here is not to list out the steps that would be required to be undertaken for turning India into a place where happiness resides. All I am trying to say is that $ 1 trillion is what is required to wipe out poverty, hunger and diseases from the country. At present India is a $ 1.3 economy, where only a fraction of the population is gaining from the massive investments being made in Bharat Nirman and urban centre growth. The inequalities are widening with the rich becoming strikingly rich and the poor being further marginalised. This has to be reversed.

Pulling out 320 million people from hunger and an estimated 470 million from below the poverty line is the kind of investments that I would utilise $ 1 trillion for. Of course, several scheme will be woven around the creation of requisite infrastructure (not palatial housing for the stinking rich) providing employment both in the rural and urban areas. Education, health and housing will remain the priority sectors. Such policies will have to be redesigned. These have to be centered around sustainable development, policies which do not lead to exploitation of natural resources, do not contaminate the environment, destroy the soil fertility, pollute water and adds to global warming.   

Real economic growth only happens when no one goes to bed hungry in a nation. This has to be on a sustainable basis. When every policy percolates to minimising hunger and poverty, why not make a direct assault to make hunger and poverty history. My $ 1 Trillion Plan would aim at not only making hunger and poverty history, but also wiping out disease and squalor.